| IDOL: underrated contestants | | there have been a couple of contestants that i think were underated when they joined american idol... either they werent praised as much or the judges favored another candidate better... which ofcourse didnt let them reach the top 3*Paris Bennett-- definitely a great singer... whenever she sings she gives me goosebumps... her performance of "take five" when she was auditioning was so good i think its on of the best ever auditions in the history of american idol*jennifer hudson-- she is now an academy award winner.. after only placing 8th during season 3... she always had the pipes and sings amazingly but the judges favored fantasia and latoya instead which led to her ouster*Camile velasco-- definitely has a good tone to ehr voicec which is rich with feelings... i dont think she was right for american idol since she has such a unique quality to her voice and was not given time to shine really with the theme nights not suiting her style... which she didnt sacrifice.. she performed songs using her own style..*nikko smith-- actually a very contemporary artist which as you know isnt really favored by the judges... he is an RnB/soul/pop... | |
| | If you had to pick 5... | | former finalists to compete in a one night, winner-take-all event, who would you select? I think it would be an awesome idea to have a "best of" show where the best five, maybe even ten, former finalists come back, get one chance to perform, and the winner takes the title of "Best American Idol" contestant not to win. I'm making it five for me cause I don't want to go that far back, but you can add more if you like. The only requirement is that the singer you select must have been a finalist in their season and did not win. (runner-ups count.)my five are (in no order)1.) Chris Daughtry (season 5)
2.) Clay Aiken (season 2)
3.) Tamyra Gray (season 1)
4.) Kimberly Locke (season 2)
5.) Jennifer Hudson (season 3)it was difficult for me to get to those conclusions: names I left out, but could be in a top 10 include:-George Huff(season 3), Paris Bennett(season 5), Josh Gracin (season 2), Diana DeGarmo (season 3), and Latoya London (season 3). Who would you pick? | |
|
| american idol: all stars! | | wouldnt it be nice if there'd be an american idol all stars? and just in case thered be one who do you think should be in it? ofcourse the contestant shouldnt have landed in the top 3 of any seasonofcourse there should be 6 girls and 6 guys my picks
(not in order)tamyra gray
paris bennett
camille velasco
john peter lewis
constantine maroulis
george huff
nadia turner
frenchie davis
mario vasquez
melissa mcghee
josh gracin
rj heltonpeople who already achived super stardon like chris daughtry and jennifer hudson are disqualified ofcourselooking back there arent alot of strong male singers.... anyway share your thoughts people!!! | |
| | who should have won?? | | Ok, with all the post about past idols, here are the winners and top 5 from all seasons. I want to know if you think the right one one, or if it should have been one of the others.Tell me what you think!!
Season 1:
Kelly Clarkson
Justin Guarini
Nikki McKibbin
Tamyre Gray
RJ HeltonSeason 2:
Ruben
Clay
Kimberley Locke
Josh Gracin
TrenyceSeason 3:
Fantasia
Diana DeGarmo
Jasmine Trias
Latoya London
George HuffSeason 4:
Carrie Underwood
Bo Bice
Vonzell Solomon
Anthony Federov
Scott SavolSeason 5:
Taylor Hicks
Katharine McPhee
Elliott Yamin
Chris Daughtry
Paris Bennett
| |
|
